Best of Show
2012 The Walking Dead: The Complete First Season — Special Edition, Anchor Bay
2011 Alien Anthology (Blu-ray), Fox
2010 Never Sleep Again: The Elm Street Legacy, CAV Distributing/1428 Films
2009 Hellraiser Box Set, Anchor Bay
Best Theatrical Disc
2012 Rise of the Planet of the Apes, Fox
2011 Insidious, Sony Pictures
2010 Trick ’R Treat, Warner
2009 The Last House on the Left (2009), Universal
Best Direct-To-Video
2012 Quarantine 2: Terminal, Sony Pictures
2011 Frozen, Anchor Bay
2010 Never Sleep Again: The Elm Street Legacy, CAV Distributing/1428 Films
2009 Alien Raiders, Warner
Best Catalog/Re-Release
2012 Evil Dead 2: 25th Anniversary Edition, Lionsgate
2011 Dark Night of the Scarecrow, VCI
2010 Friday The 13th: Part VII — The New Blood, Paramount
2009 Friday the 13th: Deluxe Editions (Parts 1-6), Paramount
Best Collection
2012 Battle Royale: The Complete Collection, Anchor Bay
Best TV on Disc
2012 The Walking Dead: The Complete First Season — Special Edition, Anchor Bay
2011 Thriller: The Complete Series, Image
2010 True Blood: Season 2, HBO
2009 Dexter: Season 3, Paramount/CBS
Best Indie or Foreign Film
2012 The Last Circus, Magnolia
2011 I Saw the Devil, Magnolia
2010 Grace, Anchor Bay
2009 [REC], Sony Pictures
Spookiest Kidvid
2012 A Nightmare Before Christmas 3D, Disney
Best Extras
2012 True Blood: The Complete Fourth Season, HBO
2011 Alien Anthology, Fox
Best Packaging
2012 Dark Shadows: The Complete Original Series, MPI
2011 Alien Anthology (Limited-Edition Egg), Fox
2010 Friday The 13th Deluxe Editions, Paramount
2009 Hellraiser Box Set, Anchor Bay
Best Box Art
2012 Rise of the Planet of the Apes, Fox
2011 Forget Me Not, Phase 4
Best Big Bad
2012 Cinderhella, Detention, Sony Pictures
2011 Dexter Morgan, Dexter: The Fourth Season, Paramount/CBS
Best Kill
2012 The Woodchipper, Tucker and Dale vs. Evil, Magnolia
2011 The Gut-Wrenching Escape, Machete, Fox
Best Line
2012 "I don’t care what happens as long as I get to kill shit!" — Jessica, True Blood: The Complete Fourth Season, HBO
2011 "Machete don't text." Machete, Fox
Best Blu-ray Disc
2010 True Blood: Season 2, HBO
2009 Ghostbusters, Sony Pictures
Judges' Award
2012 100 Greatest Horror Classics, Mill Creek
Horror Genres Best-of
2009 Slasher Laid to Rest, Anchor Bay
Last House on the Left (1972), Fox
Vampire/Werewolf Underworld: Rise of the Lycans, Sony Pictures
Zombie Quarantine, Sony Pictures
Ghost Story The Haunting in Connecticut, Lionsgate
Best Remastering
2009 Hellraiser, Anchor Bay
Lifetime Achievement
2010 Tom Holland
2009 Michael Felsher, Red Shirt Pictures
Most Anticipated
2012 Wrong Turn 5: Bloodlines, Fox
2011 Cabin in the Woods, Lionsgate
2010 Theatrical Disc A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010), Warner
Nontheatrical Disc 30 Days Of Night: Dark Days, Sony Pictures Home Entertainment
Re-Release Alien Anthology Blu-ray, 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment