Home Media Magazine » Hd 3 Myths Dispelled About Blu Ray Disc 13879
Font Size: A A A

At HD-3, Myths Dispelled About Blu-ray Disc

By Chris Tribbey | Posted: 11 Nov 2008

CENTURY CITY, Calif. — Reality vs. perception about Blu-ray Disc dominated discussion Nov. 11 at HD-3, the third annual high-definition conference.

The perception is that Blu-ray will be only a niche format, panelists said, while the reality is in its first two years, it’s doing better than DVD during its first two years. The perception, they said, is that digital downloading spells death for packaged media.

But reality can be found by following the money, they said. If downloadable high-definition is the future, nothing at the present time comes close to what Blu-ray offers.

“… While DVD sales, by all accounts, have held up remarkably well, get ready for Blu-ray to again be in the crosshairs, by a confederate of journalists and analysts who have one thing in common: They don’t know our business,” said Thomas Arnold, publisher of conference organizer Home Media Magazine.

A Pali Research report shows Wal-Mart moving CDs out to make room for more Blu-ray Discs. Blu-ray standalone-player prices are dropping below that magic price of $200 — one Best Buy employee predicted a $129 player for the holidays — and a massive, $25 million Blu-ray ad campaign is just underway. Studio representatives said they expected as many as 12 million new Blu-ray players — a majority likely being the PlayStation 3 — moving into American homes this holiday season.

If the state of Blu-ray in Japan is any indication, the format has nowhere to go but up: A report from Japanese Electronics and Information Technology Industries shows Blu-ray accounting for 31% of all home entertainment recorder and player sales.

And then there’s the promising results of a Blu-ray report from The NPD Group: Nine out of 10 American households now know what Blu-ray is, and 58% of people who said they were in the market for a Blu-ray player are buying one because of their HDTVs.

Studios at the conference shared where they see Blu-ray going, hardware manufacturers discussed the future of the players, software developers shared a glimpse of what’s next for BD Live, retailers hinted at their Blu-ray plans for Back Friday, and consumers old and young, heavy movie collectors and light, shared their thoughts about the future of high-definition.

Studios have done plenty of experimenting with Blu-ray, including digital copies, adding extra BD Live features, and even including a standard DVD in the same package. But the great experiment is still whether or not consumers will adopt Blu-ray over DVD, replacing their old collection for high-definition. And they agreed it will be the consumers who decide what direction Blu-ray takes.

“There’s just a lot we can do,” said Rich Marty, VP of business development for Sony Pictures Home Entertainment. “We can really reinvent the category.”

Danny Kaye, EVP of global research and technology strategy for 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment, said the titles his studio is releasing on Blu-ray — mostly action and new theatrical releases — are geared right at the early Blu-ray adopter. Yet Chris Saito, VP of marketing for Paramount Home Entertainment, said his studio is seeing traction with family films, though he conceded that the main demographic remains 25- to 49-year-old males.

Lori MacPherson, North American GM for Walt Disney Studios Home Entertainment, said the 1,000-DVD collector is a “prime candidate” for converting to Blu-ray, even though cheaper upconverting DVD players may seduce them

“Keep in mind that we are competing with upconverters for $80,” Saito said. “[But] it doesn’t matter if something’s cheap, if it’s not attractive to you.”

MacPherson agreed, saying, “It’s the difference between costume jewelry and a diamond.”

Studio representatives agreed that Blu-ray is just one of many distribution channels for their products — Kaye noted that iTunes movie rentals and purchases are hitting 50,000 a day — but only Blu-ray is capable today of delivering true 1080p picture and the best 7.1 audio codecs available. And, he added, Blu-ray is the only format that’s going to be capable of delivering 3-D movies close to the way they appeared in theaters.

“You should never lose sight of the fact it never happens overnight,” Kaye said of the hopeful consumer transition from DVD to Blu-ray.

User comments

Commented by
Posted on 2008-11-12 06:52:51

Unless Blu ray falls to the same price as divx players with the same features ie 30$ CDN they can forget it. As the investment not including disks is thousands of dollars its not worth it just to watch a Movie that I can already see in pretty good quality after downloading and burning ie 6 to a disk I don't need a mainframe computer to work with them either, a plain run of the mill computer will handle what i do.

Commented by
Posted on 2008-11-12 09:21:48

The perception that Blu-ray must displace DVD is incorrect. Cadillac and Chevy can coexist in the market, so why not BD & DVD? This doesn't mean BD is a niche--only that is a premium product. BD and DVD can happily coexist in the same household for years to come. Also, the rental market is primed for BD to overtake DVD--cost difference for the consumer is negligible, so why they not want to rent BD once they have a player? Internet downloads are overrated. It is not a service or delivery method that everyone can use. Homes don't have the right connections in the right rooms, people don't have fast enough internet connections, and others are limited by bandwidth, especially as market penetration deepens. It is also a flaw for BD-Live, and thus required firmware updates will be a continuing thorn in BD's side. Player cost is still the biggest hurdle. After that, it will be word of mouth--will people decry flaws like those seen with Ironman? Hate slow load times? Get tired of headaches from needed updates?

Commented by
Posted on 2008-11-12 10:19:01

If Blu-Ray is 'all-that', why does it need 'pushers' (i.e. Disney,Walmart, et.al....) ? Once a title has been 'digitally-remastered', or has digital special effects in it, a decent upconverting player works quite well. Tested this with (3) dvds at a local retailer & you won't care about any differences (if you could spot them). Blu-Ray has its place. Storage on Blu-Ray discs, titles showing art, museums, & nature, but for run of the mill action, comedy, or drama?...standard dvd works just fine & with an upconverter, you'll like the results. The 'hi-def' crowd & supporters blew it. Hi-def should have been pumped into computers 1st, then into video games. A huge rabid 'fan' base would have been created (marketing), who would have 'pumped' the Internet with glowing reviews. The spillover into selling studio titles would've been a wildfire. By trying to push for the general public first, the moment was lost. With over 4,000 (yes 4K) titles in my home , Blu-Ray has yet to convince me.

Commented by
Posted on 2008-11-12 13:16:59

They're just trying to lead people up the garden path. You need a huge and very expensive HD TV (at normal viewing distances) to benefit from Blu-ray's 1080p. You also need a very expensive high-end receiver & high-end speaker set-up to benefit from the best quality audio it can offer. Too many shops are trying to con customers with a 60" display showing a Blu-ray cartoon like Ratatouille or Cars, it looks a dammed sight better than it'll ever look on the 37" 720p LCD TV they might actually buy. Most HD TVs sold today are still 32" - 42" and 720p sets (which means the whole HD TV market is overwhelmingly still small 720p sets). The gap between upscalled DVD & Blu-ray is nothing like as big as the disciples evangelising for blu would have us believe. Then there's the recession & credit-crunch. In a recession people make the most of what they have, that's DVD. Blu-ray is a high margin niche, the new Laserdisc and probably with only the 5yrs the Samsung guy said it had left. Great if you


Send us , and video clips


Sign up for our Daily newsletter to receive breaking entertainment news and other features 


What was the best superhero movie of 2008?

Submit Vote
- OR -
Click here to view results